Free first step
Ahrefs backlinks check for a blog you abandoned
Before you pay for a single new link, find out what the old blog already owns. This routine takes about ten minutes and works with any backlink tool.

Where to begin
Open the referring domains report, not the backlinks list
An old blog may have thousands of raw backlinks from a handful of sites. Referring domains collapse that noise into the number that matters. Sort by traffic or Domain Rating, then read the top forty by hand.
- Referring domains tell you who vouches for you
- The target URL column tells you which pages earned it
- HTTP status tells you which of those pages can still pass value
Set the scope before you open the report
An ahrefs backlinks check goes wrong most often at the setup stage. Most bad audits come from a sheet that mixes two hosts, two date ranges or two exports, and the mistake only shows later.
Include every version of the domain
Include the www and non-www versions, plus any old subdomain the blog once used. Ahrefs and similar tools treat each host as its own target, so a sheet built on one of them quietly misses links. Run the list again after you add each variant.
Pick a window the blog actually lived in
Choose a date range that covers the years you were publishing. Links earned in that stretch show what the old writing attracted. Links dated before the blog existed on that domain usually belong to an earlier project, so drop them from the count and note why.
Keep a dated copy of the export
Save the export untouched and put today's date in the file name. Never edit the original file. In six months you will want to know what the tool reported on the day you started, and the raw file is the only honest answer.
The ten-minute routine
- 1
Pick your tool
Ahrefs, Semrush, Majestic and Moz all show referring domains. Ahrefs Webmaster Tools is free for sites you verify, and Google Search Console's Links report costs nothing and shows what Google itself has recorded.
- 2
Export referring domains
Download the list with the target URL and the first-seen date for each link. Sort by the domain's own traffic, then by Domain Rating.
- 3
Mark the dead targets
Paste the target URLs into a crawler such as Screaming Frog and flag anything that returns 404, 410 or a redirect loop. Those are links you earned and cannot use.
- 4
Read twenty links by hand
Open the linking pages. Is the link still there, is it dofollow, does the surrounding sentence still make sense for your topic?
- 5
Write a one-page verdict
Three columns: keep, repair, ignore. This sheet drives every later decision, including whether to buy more links at all.
Red flags that deserve a closer look
None of these means the blog is finished. Each one just tells you where to look first.
One donor links to every page
A single domain carrying most of the links often means one old feature, a directory listing or a sitewide footer. Open two of those pages before you count them as strong.
Anchors that repeat exactly
The same keyword phrase across dozens of anchors can point to a paid scheme you forgot about, or to a template someone else installed. Note the linking pages and decide later.
Links that end on unrelated redirects
A link that lands on a redirect to an unrelated homepage passes less than it appears to. Trace the chain once and record where it finally ends.
Rising counts with falling visits
If referring domains grow while organic visits shrink, the new links may come from pages nobody reads. That gap is worth a long look before any purchase.

What each tool shows an old-blog owner
| Tool | Best for | Weak spot |
|---|---|---|
| Ahrefs Webmaster Tools | Backlinks and broken-link reports for sites you verify | Only your own verified domains |
| Google Search Console | What Google reports for your own site | Sampled, no competitor view |
| Semrush backlink audit | Toxicity flags and exportable lists | Flags often need human review |
| Majestic | Large historical index, trust and citation figures | Interface is dense for beginners |
| Moz Link Explorer | Quick Domain Authority comparison | Smaller index than the leaders |
What to write down after the audit
- Total referring domains, and how many are on topic
- The five strongest linking domains by traffic
- Every target URL that now returns 404 or redirects somewhere unrelated
- Links that moved from dofollow to nofollow or sponsored
- Anchors that look spammy, with the linking page noted
- Pages that earned links and are worth refreshing

When a link looks lost but is not
Lost-link alerts are often noise. Crawlers revisit pages on their own schedule, so a link can drop out of a report for weeks and return later. Before you count it as gone, open the page yourself and search for the link text. The refresh test explains which of those pages are worth the trouble.
Treat a missing crawl as unknown
A missing link in one tool does not mean the page is gone. Check whether a second tool still shows it. If only one report lost it, mark the link as unknown rather than lost, and look again after a month.
Tell a dead page from a moved one
A 404 means the URL is dead, while a redirect means the content may still exist somewhere. Open the old address in a browser and watch where it lands. The answer decides whether you repair a redirect or let the link go.
Check dofollow status on the page itself
Tools sometimes lag behind when a link changes from dofollow to nofollow or sponsored. The page's own markup settles the question. Look at the rel attribute on the link. If none is present, the link is dofollow by default.
Reading the results without panic
A long list of low-quality referring domains looks scary. It usually is not. Since Penguin 4 went real-time in September 2016, Google mostly ignores junk links rather than punishing the site for them.
Disavow remains a tool for unusual cases, such as a manual action in Search Console or a clear pattern of paid links you placed yourself. For most revival projects the file stays unused, and a wrong entry can throw away a link you needed.
Look instead for what is missing. If the blog once ranked for a topic and the linking pages that supported it have vanished, you have found the gap that a few relevant new placements can fill.
And if the dead targets dominate your sheet, the next stop is the redirect map, not the marketplace.
A worked example with invented numbers
Picture a hobby blog that posted for three years and then stopped. The owner exports 1,240 raw backlinks, which collapse into 86 referring domains. Treat every number here as invented.
Sorting the sheet
Say the owner sorts those 86 domains by traffic and reads the top twenty by hand. Eleven still load and still contain the link. Four return errors, and the rest now sit on pages that discuss something unrelated to the blog's topic.
What the owner decides
The hypothetical owner keeps the eleven, repairs the four errors with redirects to the closest current post, and marks the rest as ignore. Only then does the question of new placements come up, and the answer depends on the two posts that still earn links.
Reading the result honestly
A short audit like this turns a big export into a list of actions. It does not promise a ranking. Your own sheet will look different, and that difference is exactly why the routine is worth running on your data.
It helps to write the limits down on the sheet itself. A note that says the counts came from one tool, one date range and one afternoon keeps the next review honest, and it stops a single export from being mistaken for the whole truth.
Audit questions we hear most
Is an Ahrefs backlinks check enough on its own?
Not quite. Every vendor crawls the web differently, so a link can show in one index and not another. Use two sources, usually Ahrefs or Semrush plus Search Console, and trust the links that appear in both before you act on them.
How many old links is a good number to still have?
There is no threshold. Ten relevant links from living pages beat a thousand from scraped directories. Judge by relevance and whether the linking page still exists, then compare with competitors in your niche using the same tool.
Should I disavow bad backlinks on an old blog?
Rarely. Google says it discounts most spammy links automatically. Disavow only when you received a manual action or know you paid for a clear scheme. Otherwise leave the file empty and spend the time on repairs.
Why do some links vanish between audits?
Pages get deleted, sites close, or the tool's crawler simply did not revisit them. Re-check lost links by opening the page yourself before you count them as gone.
How long should I wait before I call a link lost?
A few weeks is a fair window for a crawler to catch up with a page. If the link is still missing after a second check in a different tool, and the page itself is gone or changed, count it as lost. Until then, keep it in the unknown column.